Catching up on sleep at the weekend did not undo the damage of short nights
In a controlled laboratory study, people who slept five hours on weeknights and caught up at the weekend still ate more after dinner, gained weight and lost insulin sensitivity.
Short nights during the week and long lie-ins at the weekend is a common pattern. A team at the University of Colorado Boulder tested whether the weekend actually repays the debt.
Christopher Depner, Kenneth Wright and colleagues published the study in Current Biology in 2019. Healthy young adults lived in a sleep laboratory for about two weeks, where sleep, food and light were controlled. They were divided into three groups:
- a control group with 9 hours in bed each night,
- a group restricted to 5 hours a night throughout,
- a group restricted to 5 hours on weeknights, with a weekend in which they could sleep as much as they wanted, before returning to short nights.
What they found
- In the weekend group, people slept on average about 1.1 hours more than usual at the weekend, not enough to repay the debt.
- Both short-sleep groups ate more after dinner and gained weight.
- Insulin sensitivity fell by about 13 percent in the group that never caught up.
- In the weekend group it fell by between 9 and 27 percent, depending on the part of the body measured, so the weekend did not protect them.
- Once short nights resumed, the weekend group's body clock was disrupted further.
How to apply it
- A lie-in after a bad week is better than nothing for alertness, but it does not reverse the metabolic effects.
- Protect sleep on weeknights first, aiming for 7 to 9 hours.
- Keep wake times within about an hour across the whole week.
- Avoid late-evening snacking when you are short of sleep; that is where most of the extra calories came from.
A note on the evidence
The study was small, lasted only two weeks and took place in a laboratory. Long-term effects in daily life may differ. It does show that the body does not simply bank sleep and pay it back.
Sources
- Depner CM et al. Ad libitum weekend recovery sleep fails to prevent metabolic dysregulation during a repeating pattern of insufficient sleep and weekend recovery sleep. Current Biology, 2019. doi:10.1016/j.cub.2019.01.069




