Breakfast is not the key to weight loss, according to a review of 13 trials
For decades breakfast was called the most important meal of the day for weight control. Randomised trials tell a different story.
The belief that breakfast protects against weight gain rests largely on observational studies. People who eat breakfast tend to weigh less, but they also tend to differ in many other habits. The question is whether adding breakfast causes weight loss.
In 2019, Katherine Sievert, Flavia Cicuttini and colleagues at Monash University in Melbourne published a systematic review and meta-analysis in The BMJ. They pooled 13 randomised controlled trials that compared eating breakfast with skipping it.
What they found
- People assigned to eat breakfast consumed about 260 kcal a day more in total than those who skipped it.
- They weighed slightly more: on average 0.44 kg (about 1 lb) more over the study periods.
- Skipping breakfast did not lead to greater hunger in the afternoon.
The authors concluded that the evidence does not support recommending breakfast as a weight-loss strategy, and that caution is needed because it could have the opposite effect.
Earlier work from the University of Bath reached a related conclusion. In the Bath Breakfast Project, published in 2014, six weeks of daily breakfast did not change resting metabolic rate compared with fasting until midday.
How to apply it
- Eat breakfast if you are hungry, train in the morning or perform better with food. Skip it if you are not and it suits your schedule.
- What matters is total intake across the day. A large breakfast does not "kick-start" metabolism.
- If you do eat breakfast, make it count: protein such as eggs, Greek yoghurt or cottage cheese is more filling than refined cereal.
- If you train early on an empty stomach, make sure the next meal contains enough protein.
A note on the evidence
The trials included in the review were short, mostly lasting a few weeks, and the authors rated their quality as low. Results could differ over months or years. Even so, there is no good trial evidence that breakfast itself aids weight loss.
Sources
- Sievert K et al. Effect of breakfast on weight and energy intake: systematic review and meta-analysis of randomised controlled trials. The BMJ, 2019.
- Betts JA et al. The causal role of breakfast in energy balance and health: a randomized controlled trial in lean adults. American Journal of Clinical Nutrition, 2014.




