To lose belly fat around the organs, cardio beat weights in a meta-analysis
Visceral fat, stored around the organs, drives heart and metabolic disease. An Australian meta-analysis found aerobic exercise reduced it, while resistance training alone did not reliably do so.
Not all fat is equal. Visceral fat, stored deep in the abdomen around the liver and intestines, is far more closely linked to type 2 diabetes and heart disease than fat under the skin. A team at the University of Sydney pooled the evidence on which type of exercise reduces it.
Ilhamuddin Ismail, Nathan Johnson and colleagues published the systematic review and meta-analysis in Obesity Reviews in 2012. They included trials that measured visceral fat with scans before and after aerobic exercise, resistance training or both.
What they found
- Aerobic exercise produced a significant reduction in visceral fat.
- Resistance training on its own did not produce a significant reduction.
- In the nine studies that compared the two directly, the difference favoured aerobic exercise but did not reach statistical significance.
- Aerobic exercise reduced visceral fat even without large changes in body weight.
What it means
Cardio appears to be the more reliable tool for reducing the fat that matters most for health. Strength training still matters for muscle, blood sugar control and long-term weight management, so the best plan uses both.
How to apply it
- Do at least 150 minutes of moderate aerobic exercise a week, or 75 minutes of vigorous exercise: brisk walking, cycling, running, rowing.
- Keep two strength sessions a week alongside it.
- Track your waist, not only the scale. Waist size falls as visceral fat falls, even when weight changes little.
- Diet still matters: reducing alcohol and sugary drinks has a strong effect on abdominal fat.
- Do not rely on sit-ups. Training the abdominal muscles does not burn the fat around them.
A note on the evidence
Many of the included studies were small, and the direct comparison between aerobic and resistance training was not statistically conclusive. More recent trials suggest combined training is effective.
Sources
- Ismail I et al. A systematic review and meta-analysis of the effect of aerobic vs. resistance exercise training on visceral fat. Obesity Reviews, 2012. doi:10.1111/j.1467-789X.2011.00931.x




