Men's Active
Grey-bearded man running on a treadmill by a gym window
© Adobe Stock / #385545217
Weight loss · Fat loss

Exercise alone produced meaningful weight loss when the dose was high enough

In a 10-month supervised trial, adults who burned 400 or 600 calories per session, five days a week, lost weight without dieting. The bigger dose produced the bigger loss.

By Men's Active··2 min read

It is often said that you cannot out-train a bad diet and that exercise alone barely moves the scale. A team at the University of Kansas tested exercise alone with verified, measured doses.

Joseph Donnelly and colleagues published the Midwest Exercise Trial 2 in Obesity in 2013. Sedentary young adults with overweight or obesity were assigned to:

  • exercise burning 400 kcal per session, five days a week,
  • exercise burning 600 kcal per session, five days a week,
  • no exercise.

All sessions were supervised for 10 months, mostly on treadmills, and energy expenditure was measured. Participants were not asked to change their diet.

What they found

  • The 400 kcal group lost about 3.9 percent of their body weight.
  • The 600 kcal group lost about 5.7 percent.
  • The control group gained weight slightly.
  • Men and women responded similarly.

What it means

Exercise alone can produce clinically meaningful weight loss, around 5 percent, but it takes a high, consistent dose: roughly 250 to 300 minutes a week. Lower doses are often offset by eating a little more.

How to apply it

  • If you rely mainly on exercise for weight loss, aim for five sessions a week of 40 to 60 minutes.
  • Choose activities you can sustain at that volume: brisk walking, cycling, rowing, easy running.
  • Combine it with modest diet changes for a faster result.
  • Keep strength training twice a week to protect muscle.
  • Track your weight over months, not days.

A note on the evidence

The participants were young adults, sessions were supervised, and dropout was considerable. Unsupervised programmes usually achieve less. Results vary widely between individuals.

Sources

  • Donnelly JE et al. Aerobic exercise alone results in clinically significant weight loss for men and women: Midwest Exercise Trial 2. Obesity, 2013. doi:10.1002/oby.20145

Want more Men’s Active in your Google results?

More from Men’s Active

See all articles →