You do not need to train to failure to build muscle. Close is enough
Pushing every set until the bar stops moving is not required. What matters is how close you get, and the answer differs for size and strength.
Some lifters take every set until they cannot complete another repetition. Others stop with several left in the tank. Two recent analyses help settle where the useful line is.
In 2023, Martin Refalo and colleagues published a meta-analysis in Sports Medicine of 15 studies that compared training to failure with stopping short.
What they found
- When any definition of failure was used, there was only a trivial advantage for failure training on muscle growth.
- When the analysis looked only at momentary muscular failure, the point at which another repetition is impossible, there was no advantage over non-failure training.
- The authors concluded that there was no evidence that training to momentary failure is superior for muscle growth, and that the relationship between proximity to failure and growth may not be linear.
A later set of meta-regressions led by Zac Robinson and Michael Zourdos, also in Sports Medicine, estimated proximity to failure as repetitions in reserve. It found that training closer to failure was associated with more muscle growth, while strength gains were much less sensitive to how close sets were taken.
Putting it together
For muscle, sets need to be hard: generally within a few repetitions of failure. Going all the way adds little and increases fatigue. For strength, heavier loads matter more than squeezing out the last possible rep.
How to apply it
- Finish most sets with one to three repetitions left that you could have completed with good form.
- Take the last set of an isolation exercise, such as curls or lateral raises, to failure if you wish. The cost in fatigue is small.
- Avoid failure on heavy squats, deadlifts and presses, where technique breaks down and the risk rises.
- Be honest. Most people underestimate how many reps they have left.
A note on the evidence
Defining failure is difficult and studies have used different definitions, which is why the authors analysed them separately. Most participants were not elite lifters.
Sources
- Refalo MC et al. Influence of resistance training proximity-to-failure on skeletal muscle hypertrophy: a systematic review with meta-analysis. Sports Medicine, 2023.
- Robinson ZP et al. Exploring the dose-response relationship between estimated resistance training proximity to failure, strength gain, and muscle hypertrophy: a series of meta-regressions. Sports Medicine, 2024.




