The 16:8 fasting trial that found no extra weight loss
Eating only between noon and 8pm is one of the most popular diet rules of the past decade. When researchers tested it against three ordinary meals, the difference was close to zero.
Time-restricted eating limits food to a fixed window each day. The most common version, 16:8, means eating for eight hours and fasting for sixteen. It is often promoted as a way to lose fat without counting calories, sometimes with claims about metabolic benefits beyond weight.
In 2020, Ethan Weiss and colleagues at the University of California, San Francisco, published the TREAT trial in JAMA Internal Medicine. They randomised 116 adults with overweight or obesity, average age 46, 70 of them men. One group ate only between 12pm and 8pm. The other ate three structured meals a day. Neither group was told to restrict calories. The trial ran for 12 weeks.
What they found
- The 16:8 group lost 1.17 percent of body weight. The three-meal group lost 0.75 percent. The difference was not statistically significant.
- There were no meaningful differences in fat mass, fasting glucose, insulin, blood lipids or resting energy expenditure.
- In a subgroup measured in detail, the 16:8 group lost a significant amount of appendicular lean mass, the muscle in the arms and legs.
A larger trial pointed the same way. In 2022, Deying Liu and colleagues in Guangzhou, China, published a 12-month study in the New England Journal of Medicine. Both groups of adults with obesity followed the same calorie target, but one also ate only between 8am and 4pm. Weight loss was 8.0 kg (17.6 lb) with the eating window and 6.3 kg (13.9 lb) without it, a difference that was not statistically significant.
How to apply it
- Treat a fasting window as a tool for eating less, not a metabolic advantage. If it helps you stop late-night snacking, it can work. If it leads to large compensating meals, it will not.
- Total calories and protein matter more than timing.
- If you use a short eating window, fit enough protein into it. Losing muscle defeats much of the purpose of losing weight.
- Keep strength training in your week to protect lean mass.
A note on the evidence
TREAT was a 12-week study with a modest sample, and much of the data was collected remotely. The Chinese trial was longer but did not test a window without calorie restriction. Together they suggest that the eating window itself adds little once calories are accounted for.
Sources
- Lowe DA et al. Effects of time-restricted eating on weight loss and other metabolic parameters in women and men with overweight and obesity: the TREAT randomized clinical trial. JAMA Internal Medicine, 2020.
- Liu D et al. Calorie restriction with or without time-restricted eating in weight loss. New England Journal of Medicine, 2022.




