Mostly easy, sometimes very hard. Polarised training beat every other endurance method
Forty-eight trained athletes followed one of four endurance programmes for nine weeks. Those who kept most sessions easy and a few very hard improved their aerobic capacity by almost 12 percent.
Endurance athletes argue about how to spend their training time: long easy sessions, hard intervals, or the "comfortably hard" middle zone around threshold. Thomas Stöggl of the University of Salzburg and Billy Sperlich of the University of Würzburg compared the main approaches head to head.
Their study, published in Frontiers in Physiology in 2014, included 48 well-trained runners, cyclists, triathletes and cross-country skiers. They were randomly assigned to one of four programmes for nine weeks, with intensity controlled by heart rate:
- high volume: lots of low-intensity training,
- threshold: much of the training at a moderately hard, sustained intensity,
- high-intensity intervals,
- polarised: most sessions easy, a smaller share very hard, and little time in between.
What they found
- The polarised group improved the most. Peak oxygen uptake rose by 11.7 percent, time to exhaustion by 17.4 percent and peak speed or power by 5.1 percent.
- Speed or power at a standard lactate level improved after polarised training (8.1 percent) and interval training (5.6 percent).
- The interval group lost 3.7 percent of body mass; the other groups did not change.
- High-volume and threshold training produced no further improvement in most measures.
What it means
Easy sessions build aerobic capacity with little fatigue, which leaves energy for hard sessions to be truly hard. Training mostly in the middle zone feels productive but appears to deliver less for athletes who are already fit.
How to apply it
- Keep around three quarters or more of your endurance sessions easy, at a pace where you can talk in full sentences.
- Make one or two sessions a week genuinely hard: intervals of 3 to 5 minutes near maximum effort, such as the Norwegian 4x4.
- Limit time spent at a moderately hard pace that is neither easy nor hard.
- Use heart rate or perceived effort to keep easy days easy.
A note on the evidence
The study lasted only nine weeks, and the groups were small. The participants were already well trained, so beginners, who improve with almost any programme, may see smaller differences between methods.
Sources
- Stöggl T, Sperlich B. Polarized training has greater impact on key endurance variables than threshold, high intensity, or high volume training. Frontiers in Physiology, 2014. doi:10.3389/fphys.2014.00033




