Men's Active
Shirtless muscular man doing a heavy incline barbell bench press in a dark gym
© Adobe Stock / #328299880
Newsletter · Training · Muscle

Three-week breaks did not cost muscle over six months of training

In a Japanese trial, men who stopped training for three weeks at a time ended up with the same muscle and strength as men who never stopped.

By Men's Active··2 min read

Holidays, illness and busy months interrupt training. The fear is that a few weeks off wipes out months of work. A small but carefully designed study suggests otherwise.

Riki Ogasawara and colleagues in Japan published the trial in the European Journal of Applied Physiology in 2013. Fourteen young men were randomly assigned to two groups. Both did the same bench press programme, three sets of ten repetitions at 75 percent of their one-repetition maximum, three days a week.

  • One group trained continuously for 24 weeks.
  • The other completed three cycles of six weeks of training followed by three weeks of complete rest.

What they found

After 24 weeks, the increases in muscle size in the chest and triceps and in bench press strength were similar in both groups, even though the second group had trained for fewer weeks in total.

In the continuous group, the rate of gain slowed as the weeks went on. In the group that took breaks, size and strength dipped slightly during each rest period, then returned quickly once training restarted. An earlier study by the same team found the same pattern over 15 weeks.

What this means

Muscle that has been built once is regained faster than it was first gained. Researchers often call this muscle memory. A short break also appears to make the muscle more responsive to training when it resumes.

How to apply it

  • A week or two off for a holiday is not a setback worth worrying about.
  • After a longer break, restart at around 70 to 80 percent of your previous loads and build up over two or three weeks.
  • Keep protein intake high during time off.
  • If you cannot train fully, even one or two short sessions a week will help maintain what you have.

A note on the evidence

The study was small, used one exercise and was done in young men who had not trained before. Trained lifters may respond differently. The broader point, that a short break does not undo months of training, is consistent with other research.

Sources

  • Ogasawara R et al. Comparison of muscle hypertrophy following 6-month of continuous and periodic strength training. European Journal of Applied Physiology, 2013.
  • Ogasawara R et al. Effects of periodic and continued resistance training on muscle CSA and strength in previously untrained men. Clinical Physiology and Functional Imaging, 2011.

More from Men’s Active+

See all stories →