Men's Active
Young man adjusting the weights on a medical beam scale while weighing himself
© Adobe Stock / #129958813
Newsletter · Weight loss · Diet

Six years after The Biggest Loser, contestants burned 500 fewer calories a day than expected

An NIH study followed contestants from a television weight-loss competition for six years. Their metabolism had not recovered, even after most of the weight came back.

By Men's Active··2 min read

When the body loses weight, it burns less energy, partly because there is less of it to maintain. Metabolic adaptation describes the part of that drop that is larger than the change in body size would predict.

In 2016, Erin Fothergill, Kevin Hall and colleagues at the National Institutes of Health in the United States published a study in the journal Obesity. They measured 14 of the 16 contestants from a season of the television programme The Biggest Loser, at the start of the competition, at the end after 30 weeks, and again six years later.

What they found

  • Six years on, participants had regained an average of 41 kg (90 lb) of the weight they lost. On average they remained about 12 percent below their starting weight.
  • Their resting metabolic rate was 704 kcal a day lower than at the start of the competition.
  • After accounting for changes in body size and composition, metabolism was still about 500 kcal a day lower than expected. This adaptation had grown since the end of the competition, not faded.
  • Those who kept off the most weight showed the largest metabolic slowdown.

How to apply it

  • Expect the body to resist weight loss. Lower energy expenditure and increased appetite are normal biological responses, not personal failure.
  • Avoid extreme approaches. The contestants combined severe calorie restriction with several hours of exercise a day, far beyond what most people can sustain.
  • Plan for maintenance from the start. Regular physical activity, adequate protein and routine weighing are associated with keeping weight off.
  • Keep lifting weights. Preserving lean mass helps protect resting energy expenditure.

A note on the evidence

The study was small and observational, and the contestants experienced unusually rapid and large weight loss. The degree of adaptation is likely smaller with slower, moderate weight loss. However, the finding that the body defends against weight loss is consistent with other research.

Sources

  • Fothergill E et al. Persistent metabolic adaptation 6 years after "The Biggest Loser" competition. Obesity, 2016.

More from Men’s Active+

See all stories →