Low-carb or low-fat: Stanford's year-long trial found almost no difference
Six hundred adults spent a year on either a healthy low-carb or a healthy low-fat diet. Neither won, and neither genes nor insulin predicted who would do better.
Few nutrition debates run as long as low-carb against low-fat. Proponents of each point to mechanisms: insulin on one side, energy density on the other. There has also been interest in whether genetics or insulin response could tell people which diet suits them.
In 2018, Christopher Gardner and colleagues at Stanford University published the DIETFITS trial in JAMA. They randomised 609 adults aged 18 to 50 with a body mass index of 28 to 40 to a healthy low-fat or a healthy low-carbohydrate diet for 12 months. Both groups attended 22 instructional sessions and were taught to eat vegetables and whole foods and to minimise added sugar and refined flour. Neither group was given a calorie target.
What they found
- The low-fat group lost an average of 5.3 kg (11.7 lb). The low-carb group lost 6.0 kg (13.2 lb). The difference was not statistically significant.
- Neither a genetic pattern previously linked to fat or carbohydrate response, nor how much insulin participants secreted after a glucose drink, predicted who did better on which diet.
- Results within each group ranged widely: some people lost more than 25 kg (55 lb), others gained weight.
- LDL cholesterol moved in favour of the low-fat diet. HDL cholesterol and triglycerides moved in favour of the low-carb diet.
How to apply it
- Choose the approach you can sustain. Over a year, adherence matters more than the macronutrient split.
- Quality was common to both groups: more vegetables, fewer refined grains and added sugar, more home cooking.
- Keep protein adequate whichever way you go, especially if you train.
- If you have raised LDL cholesterol, monitor it on a low-carb diet high in saturated fat.
A note on the evidence
DIETFITS is one of the largest and longest diet comparisons of its kind, with measured outcomes and high retention. Participants were free-living, so intake was self-reported. The results match earlier meta-analyses showing that differences between named diets are small once calories are similar.
Sources
- Gardner CD et al. Effect of low-fat vs low-carbohydrate diet on 12-month weight loss in overweight adults and the association with genotype pattern or insulin secretion: the DIETFITS randomized clinical trial. JAMA, 2018.




