An ice bath after lifting reduced muscle and strength gains over 12 weeks
Cold water immersion is popular for recovery. In a controlled trial, men who used it after every strength session gained less.
Cold plunges have moved from elite sport to home gardens. They may help with soreness and alertness. For men trying to build muscle, the timing matters.
In 2015, Llion Roberts and colleagues from the University of Queensland, the Queensland University of Technology and the Norwegian School of Sport Sciences published two linked studies in the Journal of Physiology.
The training study
Twenty-one physically active men strength trained twice a week for 12 weeks. After each session, about half sat in cold water at 10°C (50°F) for 10 minutes. The others did 10 minutes of low-intensity cycling instead.
- Muscle mass and strength increased more in the active recovery group.
- In the active recovery group, type II muscle fibre size rose by 17 percent and the number of nuclei per fibre by 26 percent. Neither increased significantly in the cold water group.
The biopsy study
Nine active men did single-leg strength exercises, then either cold water immersion or active recovery, on separate occasions. Muscle samples taken over the following two days showed that the cold water reduced the activity of satellite cells, the stem cells that help muscle grow, and blunted key signals involved in building new protein.
The authors concluded that regular use of cold water immersion after strength training should be reconsidered.
How to apply it
- If muscle and strength are the priority, avoid cold plunges in the hours after lifting.
- If you enjoy cold exposure, use it on rest days, before training, or well away from strength sessions.
- For endurance athletes in competition, or anyone who needs to perform again within hours, cold water may still have a place for short-term recovery.
A note on the evidence
The training group was small, and the cold water exposure was immediately after every session. Less frequent or differently timed exposure has not been studied as well. The direction of the finding has been supported by later research.
Sources
- Roberts LA et al. Post-exercise cold water immersion attenuates acute anabolic signalling and long-term adaptations in muscle to strength training. Journal of Physiology, 2015.




