Hip thrusts and squats built the same glute muscle. Squats built more thigh
Hip thrusts light up the glutes more on muscle sensors. Over nine weeks of training, MRI showed both exercises grew the glutes equally, and squats added more quad and adductor muscle.
The hip thrust became popular because it produces more glute activation, measured with electrodes on the skin, than the squat. Activation is not the same as growth. A study led by Auburn University measured growth directly.
Daniel Plotkin, Michael Roberts and colleagues published the trial in Frontiers in Physiology in 2023. Thirty-four untrained young adults were randomly assigned to train either the hip thrust (18 people) or the back squat (16 people) for nine weeks, with the same number of sets. Muscle size was measured with MRI before and after.
What they found
- Glute muscle growth was similar in both groups at the lower, middle and upper glutes.
- The squat group gained more muscle in the quadriceps and adductors (inner thigh).
- Each group gained the most strength in the exercise it trained.
- Both groups improved their deadlift by the same amount.
- The hip thrust produced higher glute activation in the first session, but that did not predict who grew more.
What it means
Both exercises build the glutes. The squat does more for the whole leg in the same time; the hip thrust is easier on the knees and lower back for some people. Activation readings are a poor guide to which exercise builds the most muscle.
How to apply it
- If you have time for one lower-body exercise, choose the squat for more total leg muscle.
- Add hip thrusts if you want more glute volume without more knee or back loading.
- Use 3 to 4 sets of 8 to 12 reps, close to failure, twice a week.
- Go deep on squats. Full depth loads the glutes in a stretched position.
A note on the evidence
The participants were untrained, the study was short and the groups were small. Trained lifters may respond differently. The finding is consistent with research showing that load and effort matter more than activation scores.
Sources
- Plotkin DL et al. Hip thrust and back squat training elicit similar gluteus muscle hypertrophy and transfer similarly to the deadlift. Frontiers in Physiology, 2023. doi:10.3389/fphys.2023.1279170




