Men's Active
Silhouette of a man running uphill against a bright evening sky
© Adobe Stock / #715200876
Newsletter · Weight loss · Fat loss

Intervals or steady cardio for fat loss: a meta-analysis found no real winner

High-intensity interval training is often sold as the faster route to a leaner body. Pooling the randomised trials gives a less dramatic answer.

By Men's Active··2 min read

High-intensity interval training alternates short, hard efforts with recovery. Moderate-intensity continuous training is the steady jog, ride or row. Interval training has been promoted as superior for fat loss, partly on the strength of an earlier meta-analysis that was later retracted.

In 2021, James Steele of Solent University in the UK, with Brad Schoenfeld of Lehman College in New York and colleagues, published a systematic review and meta-analysis in the journal Sports. They included randomised trials that directly compared interval training with moderate continuous training, measured body composition with a validated method, and lasted at least four weeks.

What they found

  • The difference between the two approaches in fat mass loss was trivial, with a precise estimate.
  • The difference in fat-free mass was also trivial.
  • Compared with no exercise, both approaches produced small reductions in fat mass.
  • The authors rated the certainty of these findings as high and concluded that the pattern of intensity has minimal influence on body composition change.

How to apply it

  • Choose the form of cardio you can sustain week after week. Total activity over months matters more than the format.
  • Intervals are useful when time is short and for improving fitness. They are demanding and harder to recover from when done often.
  • Steady cardio is easier to accumulate in larger volumes and fits around strength training with less fatigue.
  • For fat loss, diet does most of the work. Cardio adds to the energy deficit; strength training helps preserve muscle.

A note on the evidence

The included trials were generally short and varied in protocols and populations. Most did not control diet closely. Even so, the analysis was pre-registered and the results were consistent: neither format has a meaningful advantage for fat loss.

Sources

  • Steele J et al. Slow and steady, or hard and fast? A systematic review and meta-analysis of studies comparing body composition changes between interval training and moderate intensity continuous training. Sports, 2021.

More from Men’s Active+

See all stories →