Cardio lost more fat, weights built more muscle. Doing both did both
An eight-month Duke University trial compared aerobic training, resistance training and the two combined in overweight adults. Each had a clear job.
For men who want to lose fat, the choice between cardio and weights comes up again and again. A trial at Duke University compared them directly over eight months.
Leslie Willis, Cris Slentz, William Kraus and colleagues published the results, from the STRRIDE AT/RT trial, in the Journal of Applied Physiology in 2012. Sedentary adults with overweight or obesity were randomly assigned to one of three programmes, and 119 completed the study:
- aerobic training: the equivalent of about 19 km (12 miles) of jogging a week at a vigorous intensity,
- resistance training: three days a week, three sets of 8 to 12 repetitions on eight machines,
- both programmes combined.
Diet was not changed.
What they found
- The aerobic group and the combined group lost more body weight and more fat mass than the resistance group.
- The resistance group and the combined group gained lean mass; the aerobic group did not.
- The combined group was the only one that lost fat and gained lean mass, but it also spent about twice as long training.
- Per hour spent training, aerobic exercise was the most efficient way to reduce fat.
How to apply it
- If fat loss is the main goal and time is limited, aerobic training gives the most return per hour.
- Keep at least two short strength sessions a week to protect and build muscle, especially when losing weight.
- If you have the time, combining both gives the best overall change in body composition.
- Diet still matters most for fat loss. Exercise alone produced modest changes in this trial.
A note on the evidence
The participants were sedentary and overweight, and the aerobic dose was substantial. Leaner, trained men may respond differently. Muscle gain also has benefits for metabolic health and ageing that a fat-loss comparison does not capture.
Sources
- Willis LH et al. Effects of aerobic and/or resistance training on body mass and fat mass in overweight or obese adults. Journal of Applied Physiology, 2012. doi:10.1152/japplphysiol.01370.2011




