Being unfit carried a risk comparable to smoking in a study of 122,000 patients
Researchers measured fitness on a treadmill rather than asking people how much they exercised. They found no upper limit to the benefit.
Most studies on exercise and lifespan ask people how active they are. People tend to overestimate. A Cleveland Clinic study avoided that problem by measuring fitness directly.
In 2018, a team led by Kyle Mandsager and Wael Jaber published an analysis in JAMA Network Open of 122,007 patients who completed a treadmill exercise test at the clinic between 1991 and 2014. They were followed for a median of 8.4 years, and 13,637 died during that time.
Patients were grouped by how their performance compared with others of the same age and sex: low (bottom 25 percent), below average, above average, high, and elite (top 2.3 percent).
What they found
- Risk of death fell at every step up in fitness.
- Elite performers had about 80 percent lower risk of death than low performers, after adjustment for other factors.
- Elite performers also had about 23 percent lower risk than the high group.
- There was no observed upper limit of benefit. The fittest were the least likely to die.
- The authors reported that low fitness was associated with a risk comparable to, or greater than, that of traditional risk factors such as smoking, diabetes and coronary artery disease.
Why it matters
Fitness is measurable and it can be changed. Unlike age or genetics, it responds to training within weeks. The study also eased a concern raised by earlier research that very high amounts of exercise might harm the heart. In this group, the fittest did best.
How to raise it
- Build a base of easy aerobic work: two to three sessions a week at a pace where you can still hold a conversation.
- Add one session of harder intervals, such as 4 minutes hard and 3 minutes easy, repeated four times.
- Be consistent for months. Fitness is lost faster than it is gained.
A note on the evidence
The patients were referred for a treadmill test, so they were not a random sample of the population. The study was observational, and genetics and other habits may contribute to both fitness and survival. The direction of the finding, however, matches decades of research.
Sources
- Mandsager K et al. Association of cardiorespiratory fitness with long-term mortality among adults undergoing exercise treadmill testing. JAMA Network Open, 2018.




